Can you include some pie charts or graphs to make more sense of your rambling?
[QUOTE=CoffeeFan;2657407]Can you include some pie charts or graphs to make more sense of your rambling?[/QUOTE]
Tai Chi is for health, Aikido helps in everyday life, MT and BJJ are for the ring with rules, and systema, booj, Krav are for reals.
[QUOTE=It is Fake;2657410]Tai Chi is for health, Aikido helps in everyday life, MT and BJJ are for the ring with rules, and systema, booj, Krav are for reals.[/QUOTE]
Nah, Aikido is an educative to learn the basics of keys and locks.
Krav and Booj are designed for real life, ideally against people who can’t fight. They are useless against a proper Randori in the ring.
MT and BJJ are designed for the ring, ideally against a guy who practices the same martial art, or one so different that he’s clueless (E.g getting down a Full-MT when you know grappling)
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657413]Nah, Aikido is an educative to learn the basics of keys and locks.
Krav and Booj are designed for real life, ideally against people who can’t fight. They are useless against a proper Randori in the ring.
MT and BJJ are designed for the ring, ideally against a guy who practices the same martial art, or one so different that he’s clueless (E.g getting down a Full-MT when you know grappling)[/QUOTE]
So, what you are saying is, if a booj guy meets a MT/BJJ guy in the street the booj guy wins, but, if in a ring because the rules remove the deadly booj techniques, the MT/BJJ guy wins?
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657413]Nah, Aikido is an educative to learn the basics of keys and locks.
Krav and Booj are designed for real life, ideally against people who can’t fight. They are useless against a proper Randori in the ring.
MT and BJJ are designed for the ring, ideally against a guy who practices the same martial art, or one so different that he’s clueless (E.g getting down a Full-MT when you know grappling)[/QUOTE]In summary:
Tai Chi is for health, Aikido helps in everyday life, MT and BJJ are for the ring with rules, and systema, booj, Krav are for reals.
You just added more words. That’s why coffefan said:
to make more sense of your rambling?
I’ll take Coffefan’s comment and Ke?po fist’s comment and make it mine. Then take the OP’s response to Ke?po fist’s to say feel free to fuck yourself it was a legitimate comment. IMO you’re the troll here.
[QUOTE=Pharabus;2657414]So, what you are saying is, if a booj guy meets a MT/BJJ guy in the street the booj guy wins, but, if in a ring because the rules remove the deadly booj techniques, the MT/BJJ guy wins?[/QUOTE]
Exactly. It’s a game of Rock-Paper-Dogshit.
Oops. He started this in MABS, it was moved to newbietown and then he created this new thread. Since he said it wasn’t about an introduction, the threads will be merged.
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657413]Nah, Aikido is an educative to learn the basics of keys and locks.
Krav and Booj are designed for real life, ideally against people who can’t fight. They are useless against a proper Randori in the ring.
MT and BJJ are designed for the ring, ideally against a guy who practices the same martial art, or one so different that he’s clueless (E.g getting down a Full-MT when you know grappling)[/QUOTE]
I think you would be better off if you spent less time trying to pigeonhole various martial arts into your burgeoning classification system and a whole lot more time training.
Martial theorists are a dime a dozen. Martial artists are not.
Now that I have the full background about your post it is about as bad as I thought.
Go get some more training and Martial education.
[QUOTE=Pharabus;2657414]So, what you are saying is, if a booj guy meets a MT/BJJ guy in the street the booj guy wins, but, if in a ring because the rules remove the deadly booj techniques, the MT/BJJ guy wins?[/QUOTE]
Nah, totally not at all. Depends on way too many factors in the street.
If a MT/BJJ just pops guard up in front of a Booj/Krav in the street, he has more odds IMHO
If a MT/BJJ starts slowly to get agressive towards a Booj/Krav, and the Booj/Krav suddently attacks, MT/BJJ has odds of losing an elbow.
If the fight happens with a lot of improvised weapons around, tilts the balance for Booj/Krav.
If the fight happens in a tight area, also.
If both have a gun, it gets mostly random.
If they are both snipers, tilts the balance for the one with the best eyes (Therefore not me)
If in happens in the Matrix, tilts the balance for the most dynamic and impressive visually combat style.
If it happens at Dillman’s, tilts the balance twoards the least brainwashed.
See? So many factors :LOL:
Dear Dianth.
I am confused. Why would you post here? Don’t get me wrong. It is not my problem that you post here and it doesn’t upset me in anyway. I simply can’t understand the reasoning behind it.
[QUOTE=Uglybugly;2657433]Dear Dianth.
I am confused. Why would you post here? Don’t get me wrong. It is not my problem that you post here and it doesn’t upset me in anyway. I simply can’t understand the reasoning behind it.[/QUOTE]
Please clarify your question.
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657434]Please clarify your question.[/QUOTE]
Is the written words not obvious?
[QUOTE=Tom .C;2657441]Is the written words not obvious?[/QUOTE]
Not really, “here” is ambiguous.
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657427]
If a MT/BJJ just pops guard up in front of a Booj/Krav in the street, he has more odds IMHO
If a MT/BJJ starts slowly to get agressive towards a Booj/Krav, and the Booj/Krav suddently attacks, MT/BJJ has odds of losing an elbow.
If the fight happens with a lot of improvised weapons around, tilts the balance for Booj/Krav.
If the fight happens in a tight area, also.
If both have a gun, it gets mostly random.
If they are both snipers, tilts the balance for the one with the best eyes (Therefore not me)
If in happens in the Matrix, tilts the balance for the most dynamic and impressive visually combat style.
[/QUOTE]
Dude, seriously. :WhyWithHands:
[QUOTE=Rzero;2657463]Dude, seriously. :WhyWithHands:[/QUOTE]
What?
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657469]What?[/QUOTE]
He is unhappy about the fact that you’re equating the Bujinkan with Krav Maga.
UglyBugly is confused as to why you’d post your opening post here on Bullshido, a place where martial theorists are not welcomed in general. They love theorists over at MAP though.
[QUOTE=jnp;2657470]He is unhappy about the fact that you’re equating the Bujinkan with Krav Maga.[/QUOTE]
I’m not. The whole post comparing Krav and Booj to MT and BJJ was a joke. You can’t compare these two categories.
You could try to compare Booj and Krav, and it would be a bit useless. Seems boring to me…
[QUOTE=jnp;2657470]UglyBugly is confused as to why you’d post your opening post here on Bullshido, a place where martial theorists are not welcomed in general. They love theorists over at MAP though.[/QUOTE]
I’m not really a theorist. I love this forum for serious investigations about BS, and yet I’m a bit annoyed by MMA-fanboys who compare Aikido to Muay Thai. The only point of my post here is to:
-Proove that not all RBSD guys despise MMA, and that some of us still have respect.
-Laugh at MMA/RBSD fanboys raging on Tai Chi.
-Have fun sharing memes.
The theory behind it is very obvious, and it’s actually an anti-theory, since I refute comparison of style category. Which theorists do all the time.
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657474]I’m not. The whole post comparing Krav and Booj to MT and BJJ was a joke. You can’t compare these two categories.
You could try to compare Booj and Krav, and it would be a bit useless. Seems boring to me…
I’m not really a theorist. I love this forum for serious investigations about BS, and yet I’m a bit annoyed by MMA-fanboys who compare Aikido to Muay Thai. The only point of my post here is to:
-Proove that not all RBSD guys despise MMA, and that some of us still have respect.
-Laugh at MMA/RBSD fanboys raging on Tai Chi.
-Have fun sharing memes.
The theory behind it is very obvious, and it’s actually an anti-theory, since I refute comparison of style category. Which theorists do all the time.[/QUOTE]
Maybe you’re new to the internet, but this,
[QUOTE=Dianth;2657427]Nah, totally not at all. Depends on way too many factors in the street.
If a MT/BJJ just pops guard up in front of a Booj/Krav in the street, he has more odds IMHO
If a MT/BJJ starts slowly to get agressive towards a Booj/Krav, and the Booj/Krav suddently attacks, MT/BJJ has odds of losing an elbow.
If the fight happens with a lot of improvised weapons around, tilts the balance for Booj/Krav.
If the fight happens in a tight area, also.[/QUOTE]
is called equating one thing with another as signified by your use of the forward slash. It can also mean they are interchangeable, which would also be equating one with the other.
Is English your second language?