Am I Bullshido???

Here is the situation…

My Master put my number on a directory so that we can expand our advertising.

my ad says “TKD blah blah blah, TKD”. Now I have been in TKD now for about 7 years, and teach TKD to kids, however, I was never into the super traditional stuff nor the pure TKD stuff.

never good at the high flying kicks, my Korean sucks, so… i teach the more practical aspects. well timed round kick etc. every now and then i teach them how to throw low kicks, knees, elbows, and take downs.

We still call the class TKD because it is TKD based and TKD style sparring. (full padding, the works) with extreme emphasis on kicking and speed.

So, I got a call yesterday, some TKD purest calls. tells me he has trained under place Korean name here, and is looking for a good TKD/korean martial art school.

get this, he says most of his training is Tang Soo Do, he wants his son to try the martial arts, and is bent on taking korean martial arts only.

He then asks me about forms, or Poomsae. “I have used the Chun Ji forms, and im looking for a school who uses those forms”. (I am dumbfounded)

me-“we teach Taeguek forms…”

He then asks about weapons, i tell him we don’t do weapons.

he goes into talking about his korean master and how fuckin great he was.

now im thinking Korean weapons???

I end the conversation with telling him that the best possible way to answer all of his questions is for him and his son to try a week of classes free of charge, just to see if we have what he’s looking for.

So, my question…

am I bullshido for claiming that I teach TKD when I actually teach more practical TKD? (without the flying kicks, korean terminology, etc)

We still do other types of trad. stuff, such as bow to the flags, bow before a match, shake hands w/instructor etc.

Bullshido for taking TKD.

End of thread.

If you have to ask…

You are bullshido for calling yourself the MMA kid with just 3 months grappling experience.

Who is your BJJ instructor?

his name is Isreal Marquez

He then asks about weapons, i tell him we don’t do weapons.

he goes into talking about his korean master and how fuckin great he was.

now im thinking Korean weapons???

The Koreans used a fairly distinct style of bow. And uhm, they were the first to use gunpowder as a real weapon.

Other then that, the rest of their weapons are Chinese or Japanese weapons with funny Korean names.

What are his credentials? What rank does he hold and which instructor gave it to him?

credentials…

havent asked for it. he is a good instructor,

I guess his ability to kick my ass…

he’s done well in a few tournaments.

i take the class for free since he is friends with my instructor, so i havent researched him.

i cant really represent him since i don’t know him that well.

to the best of my knowledge, he looks legit.

Not on BJJ.org. I’m guessing a blue belt

Im planning to get a video camera soon, I guess I’l post it in a proper thread as soon as i get it. but that is gonna be a while.

hmmm…

not much that i can say to defend him at the moment…

why would you say he is a blue belt?

he has a black belt

do you know his rank or does he only teach no-gi?

coughs nobody has really addressed my question yet (with the exception of megaJ)

he wears a gi.

he doesnt wear anything but a solid black belt.

Im guessing standard first degree

first degree black belt in BJJ? Are you sure of the name? A first degree black belt would surely be on BJJ.org.

I didn’t know that.

Israel Marques

Israel Marquez

thats the only possible way i think to spell or misspell his name.

How do you know he is a good instructor? Do you have any basis for comparison that would allow you to make such a judgement?

Most white belts can kick untrained peoples ass. I choked out a karate black belt when I was a white belt, it ment nothing about my overall skill (which was jack shit).

Which tournents did he do well in? what division? “Doing well” could mean anything from sandbagging and beating up noobs to winning absolute.

To the best of your knowledge? You don’t seem to have very much knowledge about him. How many lessons have you had with him? On the average how many hours of BJJ mat time do you get per week? Do you actually go to a BJJ school for this or is he just teaching you and other TKDists at your dojang?

I will have to ask him about his credentials.

good point to raise, however, not going to defend or bash a man i know little about

but, I am a much better grappler than i was when i started, (which was 0 grappling)

other people from other schools have grappled there before. but still dont know were THOSE students came from either

Well if your not teaching TKD as traditional TKD but you are advertising as such … then … yeah … your full of shit …

Not to say that in this case it isnt “good” for the students …as you are claiming they are actually learning to defend themselves . But if you are not teaching what you advertise … you are misrepresenting your art and misleading the public …

my instructor hired him to teach BJJ at my dojang.

I have no basis of comparison.

i train 3 hours a week (roughly) on BJJ

the children’s class is the only TKD course.

kickboxing for the adults.

so he is teaching the adults (all noobs) BJJ